• Home
  • Contact
  • US Envoy
    • Undocumented Irish
  • Biography
  • Memorial
  • Recent
  • Data Privacy Policy
John Deasy T.D.

ISSUES

Dungarvan pig farmer’s case to be reviewed

22/6/2015

0 Comments

 

John Deasy: strong perception locally that he was poorly treated by Department

Picture
The Department of Agriculture has told Waterford TD John Deasy that it will direct a special steering committee to review the circumstances in which a Dungarvan farmer was compelled to slaughter 4,000 pigs at a loss of almost €750,000.

Speaking at last Thursday’s meeting of the Dáil Public Accounts Committee, which discussed the Department’s handling of the 2002 mass destruction of pigs at the Ballinamuck farm of Tom Galvin, Secretary General Aidan O’Driscoll said they would not allow a similar situation to unfold again.

“There’s no doubt that that. There are many aspects of this that we wouldn’t handle the same way. If we did allow on-farm slaughter we would supervise the whole thing.”

Outlining the case history, he told how traces of Carbadox — banned in the EU in 1999 because of its carcinogenic properties but still legal in the United States — were found in a pig carcass traced to Mr Galvin’s farm, where officials later found several bags of the product.

Mr Galvin was convicted under animal remedy regulations but successfully appealed the verdict. The Department did not defend the appeal on the basis that the Supreme Court had decided that the Minister did not have the right to amend regulations.

Deputy Deasy, vice-chairman of the PAC, told the Secretary General: “When it comes to Tom Galvin, I have to say he’s someone who’s very well regarded and the feeling locally would be that the Department treated him poorly, and that’s my own subjective view having looked at the evidence.”

Deasy said he’d formed this opinion “regardless of the constraints Department officials might have been under when it comes to the rules and regulations in dealing with animals suspected of being diseased, or fed things allegedly that would affect the food chain adversely.”

Mr O’Driscoll, stressing “he’d no axe to grind” with Mr Galvin and “he could well be a fine person, as you’ve said”, explained why officials entered the farm and that the farmer admitted spreading the product on the floor of his pig pens.

“Once that admission was made, effectively the pigs had to be slaughtered,” he said. No further testing took place. Mr Deasy wondered why not, if only for clarity’s sake. Mr O’Driscoll acknowledged “there must have been a test we could have done, yes.”

The Fine Gael TD disagreed with his contention that “there would have been nothing served” by testing the pigs on the farm. If it had produced “incontrovertible evidence as to what might have gone into the food chain, I think it would have solved an awful lot of problems subsequently.”

Though accepting the Department has to act in cases involving threats to the food chain, “I think you made a mistake — and left a real grey area about the state of those pigs — by not going down that road [testing],” he said. Mr O’Driscoll agreed that this was a reasonable assessment.

The Department had told Mr Galvin to have the pigs destroyed in an approved plant as they must not enter the food chain. Instead, he asked to carrying out the slaughter on his property using a humane killer. 

The Secretary General said the disposal of the carcasses was supervised by a Department official at all times. Around 25 percent of the slaughter was overseen by a veterinary official and it was done “meticulously”.

Mr O’Driscoll — who refuted an allegation that a Department official overseeing the slaughter had handed Mr Galvin a lump hammer and told him to finish the job — said he understood that about 10 animals were killed in this way before the vet intervened and took away the hammer.

Mr Deasy said that for the Department to admit it wouldn’t allow such a scenario to unfold again “is significant”. The fact that the Veterinary Council had exonerated the vets involved was “fair enough” but “that doesn’t mean that things that happened were done properly” or that this “should have occurred the way that it did.”

Mr O’Driscoll said: “You’re quite right — if we did this again I’m quite sure we wouldn’t do it in the same way and in the same circumstances. In particular, if we did allow on-farm slaughter by the farmer I think we would supervise the entire thing. Would we allow [it] at all? I don’t know, I’d be unwilling to say definitely not.”

Deputy Deasy said, “It amazes me that when it comes to the obvious, potentially devastating financial result that did occur that only 25% of the slaughter was actually supervised” — compounded by the fact that procedures didn’t change even after the alleged use of a lump hammer; which Mr O’Driscoll regarded as “a fair point”.

Having been “constructively made [to] slaughter those pigs himself,” he deemed it “understandable” why Mr Galvin asked permission to do so on his own farm, given that he’s gone to a couple of abattoirs who refused, presumably because they didn’t want any potentially contaminated pigs going into the foods chain. Plus, “it was probably the cheaper option at the time.”

Mr O’Driscoll had “no problem with that interpretation”. The only other option would have been to bring a professional slaughterman onto the farm, “and I think if we were doing it again that option would be quite a prominent one.”

In his opinion, “The key error we made was not having 100% supervision.” However, Mr Deasy maintained this was “not the only mistake really”. First off, when that singular pig was believed to have tested positive, the Department left Mr Galvin “remain in a state of limbo for three months.”

He couldn’t understand how, “if it was so crucial that those pigs were slaughtered, why did you wait three months? It seems to me it really was a haphazard approach by the Department.”

During that time, the pigs got sick, disease spread, medicines were taken away from the farmer, and he moved animals in that interim period; “probably because he needed cash to keep going.”

The Secretary General said because Mr Galvin contested the slaughter order in the High Court, which found against him, a lot of delay before the slaughter took place “related to those legal issues.”

Deputy Deasy also said Mr Galvin “would contend that the manner in which those pigs were slaughtered was not correct”. Mr O’Driscoll said the method the farmer had used was very widely applied in the UK during the swine fever outbreak two years previously.

Another option was the Department could have taken over the pigs and got them slaughtered — but the legal advice was that it would have ended up having to pay significant compensation. “Would that have been a better outcome?” the Secretary General asked. “Not for the taxpayer.”

But, Mr Deasy said, “You could certainly make the argument, for fairness sake, it might have been the best option.” He added that, notwithstanding the disease risks associated with the movement of animals and so on, “there’s also the question of treating somebody fairly, and when I look at this I think, actually, he was treated poorly”.

On account of a product that’s still not banned in the U.S. to this day, he’d been left out of pocket to the amount of €0.75m.

With a 2005 review of the case conducted without Mr Galvin’s input, and its findings still unpublished, Mr Deasy said: “I think your new steering group within the Department should take another look at this, for the sake of fairness to the individual in question who was put out of business... and at least offer him the opportunity, outside of an adversarial setting, to make his case.”

The Secretary General had “no difficulty with that” and said the best thing he could do was to refer the 2005 internal report to the steering group for its consideration, and also hand it over to the PAC. Mr Galvin could make a submission to the steering group, “if he wants to contest anything that’s in the report, or just present his own narrative.”

0 Comments

    FastFinder

    All
    1916
    2016
    Advance Factory
    Aer Lingus
    Agriculture
    AIB
    Airport
    Alleged Abuse
    Ambassador
    Amendments
    American Embassy
    Angling
    Anne Anderson
    Anne Marie Tierney Le Roux
    Anne-Marie Tierney-Le Roux
    Ann-Marie Tierney-Le Roux
    Apple Market
    Ardscoil Na Mara
    ARV
    Ballinamuck
    Bank Of Ireland
    Banks
    Bausch + Lomb
    Bell Lines
    Belview
    BIM
    Blackwater
    Bord BIa
    Breakwater
    Bridge
    British Soldiers
    Buildings
    Bus
    Business
    Bus Shelter
    Butlerstown
    Bypass
    Camphire
    Carriganore
    Cataract Surgery
    China
    Chuck Schumer
    City
    Civilians
    Coast
    Coast Guard
    Commemorations
    Commercial
    Comptroller And Auditor General
    Copper Coast
    Cork
    Council
    Councils
    Cruise Ships
    Crystal Pitch
    Cybercrime
    Dairy
    Dairy Equipment Scheme
    Dairy Forum
    Dairying
    Damien Geoghegan
    Defence Forces
    Deise Greenway
    Deloitte
    Department Of Agriculture
    Department Of Education
    Department Of Finance
    Department Of Health
    Department Of Public Expenditure And Reform
    Department Of Transport
    Diverse Campus Services
    Dowds
    Dredging
    Dublin Castle
    Dungarvan
    Dungarvan United
    Dunmore East
    Easter Rising
    Education
    EIB
    Employment
    Enterprise
    Enterprise Ireland
    EPA
    Error
    EU
    European Commission
    Europol
    Eyesight
    Failte Ireland
    Farming
    FDI
    Fine Gael
    Fishing
    Fishing Port
    Food And The Marine
    Football
    Forensics
    Foster Home
    Frank Daly
    Frank Ronan
    Frank Ryan
    Fraud
    Free Trade
    Free Travel
    Funding
    Garda
    Garda Commissioner
    Geopark
    Gerry Murphy
    Glanbia
    Glandore
    Global Intelligence
    GPO
    Gymnastics Club
    Harbour
    Haulage
    Hauliers
    HEA
    Health
    Helicopter
    HGVs
    Higher Education Authority
    Hogan
    Horse Trials
    Hospital
    Howard Schmidt
    Howlin
    HSE
    IBRC
    ICA
    IDA
    IDA Ireland
    IFA
    Impaired Vision
    Industry
    Inner City
    Institute
    International
    Investment
    Investors
    Inward Investment
    Ireland's Ancient East
    Ireland Strategic Investment Fund
    Irish Civil War
    Irish Dairy Board
    Irish Volunteers
    Irish Water
    ISIF
    Jobs
    John Deasy
    John McGuinness
    John Treacy
    Julie Sinnamon
    Kieran Byrne
    Kilmacthomas
    Kilrush Park
    Legislation
    Leisure Craft
    Lewis Merletti
    Liam Brazil
    Living City Initiative
    Local Authority
    Managers
    Manufacturing
    Marine
    Martin Shanahan
    McGinley
    Mercyhurst College Ireland
    Michael Creed
    Michael Ring
    Michael Street Development
    Michael Walsh
    Milk
    Milk Price
    Milk Quotas
    Milk Suppliers
    Minister Ring
    Multinationals
    Munster
    N25
    NAMA
    National Pension Reserve Fund
    National Roads Authority
    National Transport Authority
    Newgate Centre
    New York
    New Zealand
    Niamh O'Donoghue
    Nóirín O'Sullivan
    North Quays
    NRA
    NTA
    NTMA
    Olympics
    Ophthalmology
    Overpayments
    PAC
    Pigs
    Pollution
    Port
    Port Of Waterford
    Primary Care
    Private Hospitals
    Property
    Public Accounts Committee
    Public Services Card
    Quay Roadworks
    Quotas
    Rates
    Receiver
    Recovery
    Recycling Facility
    Regeneration
    Regional
    Regional Manager
    Rescue 117
    Revenue
    Richard Bruton
    Ridge School Of Intelligence Studies And Information Science
    River Bride
    RNLI
    Rochester
    Ryder Cup
    SAR
    Secondary School
    Sewage
    Sewerage Scheme
    Shandon
    Shannon
    Shaun Quinn
    Sikorsky
    Simon Coveney
    Slaughter
    Sligo
    Social Protection
    Social Welfare
    Southeast
    South East
    Sport
    Sports Council
    Summerhill
    Superlevy
    Tallow
    TAMS II
    Teagasc
    Technology Park
    Thomas Galvin
    Toll
    Tom Galvin
    Tourism
    Tramore
    Transport
    Travel Pass
    Trucks
    UHW
    Unemployment
    University
    University Hospital Waterford
    Urban Renewal
    U.S.
    Valeant
    Valuation
    Vets
    Vietnam
    VLM
    War
    War Of Independence
    Waterford
    Waterford Airport
    Waterford City
    Waterford City And County Council
    Waterford Council
    Waterford Crystal
    Waterford Greenway
    Waterford Institute Of Technology
    West Waterford
    White House
    Whitfield Clinic
    Wild Atlantic Way
    WIT
    WRH

JOHN DEASY TD

  • Constituency Office 35, O'Connell Street, Dungarvan, Co Waterford
  • Phone 058-43003​
  • Email john.deasy@oireachtas.ie

Back to Top

  • Home
  • Contact
  • US Envoy
    • Undocumented Irish
  • Biography
  • Memorial
  • Recent
  • Data Privacy Policy